What Is the Burden of Proof & Why Is It Important?

The concept of “burden of proof” is an important legal term that many people are not familiar with. It is a vital concept in our legal system as it ensures that justice is served fairly and without bias. 


In criminal defense cases, it is most often defined as the responsibility of the prosecutor to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant has committed a crime.  


Our attorneys explain what the burden of proof is, its importance in criminal defense cases, and how it affects the outcome of such proceedings. 



The Significance of the Burden of Proof 


The burden of proof is an important concept in criminal defense and civil trials. It is defined as the legal responsibility to prove a certain fact or allegation in a trial and it can either rest on the plaintiff, defendant, or both parties depending on the circumstances.  


In criminal defense cases, the burden of proof usually lies with the prosecution. This means that it is up to them to prove that the defendant committed the crime they’re being accused of.  


The jury must be convinced by this evidence before they can make a guilty verdict or find someone innocent in court. It is through this process that innocent people are protected from wrongful convictions and justice can be served accordingly. 


Who Has the Burden of Proof?  


The person or entity who brings forth a lawsuit always has the burden of proof. As such, the party that initiates must also provide evidence for their case. 


For example, since the state most often files charges in criminal cases, this burden lies with the state.  


Note: When defending your case, your defense attorney also carries this burden and will present evidence to the court to prove your innocence. 


The Three Burdens of Proof 


There are differences in the burden of proof necessary for civil and criminal cases, and they are considered the “three burdens of proof.”  


  • #1. Preponderance of the Evidence: This most often refers to civil cases. To prove their case the plaintiff must prove that each element of the case is more probable than not.  


  • #2. Beyond a Reasonable Doubt: “Beyond a reasonable doubt,” which is used in criminal trials, is based on the belief that no sane person could contest the evidence. It is the highest standard of proof.  


  • #3. Clear & Convincing Evidence: The plaintiff must demonstrate that the evidence establishes that their claim is extremely likely to be true when a case is supported by clear and compelling proof.This is again, a higher standard, and walks hand in hand with belief beyond a reasonable doubt.  


Deciphering “Beyond a Reasonable Doubt” 


In criminal cases, there is a presumption that an accused person is innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.  


Simply put, this means that for an accused individual to be found guilty of a crime and potentially face jail time, the evidence that was presented in court must be so compelling that there is no plausible defense to their innocence.


This ensures that those who are wrongfully accused have the best chance possible to walk away without being wrongfully convicted.  


It’s up to the prosecution to prove guilt through admissible evidence. 


In criminal proceedings, prosecutors are tasked with convincing a jury — and therefore the judge — beyond a reasonable doubt that an individual committed the crime they stand accused of. The burden of proof lies with them, and if they fail to do this, then it will result in either an acquittal or a hung jury. 


This means that the prosecution must provide sufficient evidence to convince the jury that each element of the offense has been established before finding someone guilty.  


Important: This doesn’t eliminate all doubt, instead, it confirms that the only reasonable answer is that the party with the burden proved their case.  


Criminal Defense & the Burden of Proof  


In a criminal trial, this burden is also important for your defense team. Since one party must prove their case to the court for them to prevail, this means that a criminal defendant must present sufficient evidence to convince a jury or judge that they are not guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.  


Any defendant must understand their rights and responsibilities when facing prosecution in court. 


When it comes to criminal defense trials, criminal defense lawyers must present their client’s case to meet the burden of proof required by the court.  


To meet these requirements, exculpatory evidence is used. This evidence could include: 


  • Witness testimonies 
  • Photographs 
  • Physical evidence such as fingerprints or DNA analysis 
  • Additionally, defendants may use expert witnesses who can provide additional information relevant to the case 


The burden of proof demands that all evidence presented in court must be reliable, convincing, and adequate to prove guilt beyond any reasonable doubt—no matter how circumstantial or corroborative it may seem.  


Any defense attorney must have comprehensive knowledge of this concept to put forward a strong case on behalf of their client during trial proceedings. 


Read More > What is Exculpatory Evidence?  


Florida Criminal Defense  


Defending your rights in a criminal case is an enormous task, but not with a skilled defense attorney on your side. Ben Stechschulte, a board-certified criminal defense lawyer and former prosecutor, is no stranger to this challenge.  


He has dedicated decades of his professional life to representing clients across the state. Both successful in winning numerous acquittals and achieving significant reductions in charges for many of his clients.  


Contact the criminal defense team at Stechschulte Nell Law for a case review today at 813-280-1244. We are ready to defend you.  

To learn more about how we can help

Contact us Today