Contact the StechLaw Criminal Defense law firm today for help. 24/7 Live Call Answering (813) 491-1073 Free Consult

Blog

What Prosecutors Must Prove About a Threat

Ben Stechschulte
aggravated assault defense lawyer Tampa, FL

A threat can lead to a felony charge even when no one is touched. Florida’s assault statutes focus on what the accused said or did, what the other person reasonably feared, and whether a weapon or a felony was involved. Each of those pieces has to be proved, and each can be challenged.

Simple Assault Sets the Baseline

Florida Statute 784.011 defines assault as an intentional, unlawful threat by word or act to do violence to another person, coupled with an apparent ability to do so, that creates a well-founded fear that violence is imminent. Simple assault is a second-degree misdemeanor. No physical touching is required. The offense rests on the threat and the fear it causes.

What Makes an Assault Aggravated

Florida Statute 784.021 raises the charge when the assault is committed with a deadly weapon without intent to kill, or with an intent to commit a felony. The offense is a third-degree felony, which carries up to five years in prison. That jump from misdemeanor to felony is why the facts about a weapon or intent receive so much attention.

The State Must Prove Each Element

The prosecution has to establish all of these:

  • An intentional, unlawful threat made by word or act
  • An apparent ability to carry out the threat
  • A well-founded fear in the other person that violence was imminent
  • Either the use of a deadly weapon without intent to kill, or an intent to commit a felony

If one piece is missing, the felony count is in trouble. Sometimes the charge can drop to a lesser offense instead.

Those charged in Hillsborough County can work with a Tampa aggravated assault defense lawyer who reviews the evidence element by element. That review starts with the arrest report and any video.

Intent Can Be Disputed

Raising a hand in frustration isn’t the same as intending a threat. Context matters, including what was said before and after, who else was present, and whether the encounter was a joke, an accident, or a heated exchange that went nowhere. Text messages, video, and witness accounts can decide this question.

Intent disputes need courtroom judgment. Ben Stechschulte, the attorney at StechLaw Criminal Defense, is a native Floridian who now lives in Tampa, is board certified in criminal trial law, and has practiced in the Tampa Bay area for nearly 15 years.

Fear and Ability Are Judged by the Situation

The statute speaks of apparent ability and a well-founded fear, so the focus is on how events appeared to the other person. Distance, lighting, objects in hand, and the history between the two people can all bear on that. Fear that isn’t reasonable, or violence that wasn’t imminent, can weaken the State’s position.

The Meaning of Deadly Weapon

The aggravated assault statute doesn’t define the term, so the question can turn on how an object was used. A firearm or knife is the obvious example, but other objects can qualify depending on how they’re used. That’s why assault without a gun can still be charged as aggravated.

Defenses Worth Examining

Several defenses can apply depending on the evidence:

  • Self-defense or defense of another
  • Mistaken identity
  • No threat was made
  • The act was accidental
  • No intent to commit a felony

A defendant who acted to protect themselves may raise Florida’s justification rules, and the basics of Florida self-defense are a good starting point. Self-defense claims depend heavily on what the defendant reasonably believed at the moment.

Cases involving force in a home or vehicle can also raise immunity questions that a Tampa stand your ground defense lawyer addresses. Immunity claims raise separate legal questions from the usual defenses.

Consequences Reach Past the Sentence

A felony conviction can affect firearm rights, employment, and housing. Even a plea to a lesser charge has a record attached. People weighing offers should understand the realistic jail time for assault before deciding how to proceed.

Related Charges Can Appear Together

An assault allegation can arrive with other counts, such as battery or a weapons offense. How those charges interact can change the strategy. The difference between assault versus battery is a common point of confusion.

Multiple counts can change the strategy from the first hearing. Clients facing several charges may rely on a Tampa violent crimes defense lawyer to work through the overlaps.

First Steps After an Accusation

Avoid discussing the incident with anyone but your attorney, and preserve any messages or video that show what happened. If you’re facing a charge in Tampa, get in touch with Ben Stechschulte so the evidence can be reviewed while it’s still fresh.

Schedule A Consultation

Contact the StechLaw Criminal Defense firm today for help.

All fields marked with an “ * ” are required