An employer who finds personal purchases on a company card has two paths. One is an internal matter handled through repayment and discipline. The other is a police report, and the line between them is thinner than most employees expect.
When a Card Dispute Becomes a Criminal Case
Most companies treat an occasional personal charge as a policy violation. The employee pays it back and the matter ends. Problems start when the amounts are large, the charges are repeated, or the employee coded them as business expenses. At that point an employer may report the conduct to law enforcement, and in Florida theft depends on intent, not on the label the company puts on it.
Prosecutors can frame the same conduct several ways. A single large purchase may be charged as theft. A pattern of purchases backed by altered receipts or false expense reports may be charged as a scheme to defraud, which treats the whole course of conduct as one offense rather than a series of small ones.
In Hillsborough County, these cases are filed in the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit, which covers only this county.
A Hillsborough County, FL white collar crime lawyer sees these cases often, and the first question is always what the company can prove about intent.
What Usually Happens First
Employees rarely learn about the problem from a detective. They learn about it from the employer, and the sequence tends to follow a pattern:
- An expense audit or a bank reconciliation flags the charges.
- The employee is called into a meeting and asked to explain each purchase.
- A written demand for repayment follows, often with a short deadline.
- The employee is terminated, sometimes the same day.
- If repayment doesn’t happen, or the amount is large, the company files a report.
The meeting is the dangerous step. Explanations given to a manager end up in a written statement that becomes the backbone of the case. Anyone who is under investigation for stealing from an employer should treat that meeting the way they would treat a police interview.
Defenses That Come Up
Authorization and Ambiguity
Many company card policies are vague or unwritten. If a manager approved similar charges before, if the card was used on a trip that mixed business and personal travel, or if the company reimbursed the same type of expense in the past, intent becomes hard to prove. At StechLaw Criminal Defense, we regularly see cases where the policy itself was never provided to the employee. That history belongs in front of a prosecutor before a filing decision is made.
Repayment and Restitution
Paying the money back does not erase a charge. But restitution changes how a prosecutor views the file, and it is often the foundation for a diversion agreement or a reduced charge. Repayment offered through counsel, with documentation, reads differently than repayment offered in a panic after termination.
Some cases involve a national bank’s records, interstate purchases, or sums large enough to draw interest from federal prosecutors. When that happens, the defense strategy shifts, and our federal criminal defense attorney handles that referral from the start.
Ben Stechschulte is board certified in criminal trial law and has represented employees and business owners in these disputes across the Tampa Bay area. If your employer has accused you of misusing a company card, speak with a Hillsborough County, FL white collar crime lawyer before you attend that meeting or sign a repayment agreement. Contact us to arrange a confidential case review.
